Heather Armstrong at Dooce posted a clip on her website yesterday of Sarah Palin talking to Katie Couric about her foreign policy credentials. Palin’s main point seems to be that since she is sandwiched between Alaska and Canada, she is used to dealing with other countries, even though she hasn’t ever actually had official dealings with the federal governments of either country. Heather, a Democrat, asked any Palin supporters out there who were willing to comment to come forward and talk about why they’d consider voting for such a woman.
I’ve read a couple hundred comments so far, and there hasn’t been much Palin support.
What there has been, however, is dozens and dozens of thoughtless, insulting, and borderline crazy comments from so-called Democrats. I’m not American, so I’m not there, I’m not in it, and maybe I don’t have the same passion as these people. It seems to me, however, that the Democrats in America are never going to succeed because their party is full of idiots on the internet who do not know how to engage in debate such that they aren’t acting like elitist snobs who have no respect for other points of view.
There are many people on Heather’s blog with smart, interesting things to say. But there are even more who say things like, “Palin is the antichrist” or “I just ralphed a little in my mouth listening to this clip” and “if McCaine [sic] and Palin are elected, I’m moving to Canada.” These statements are not helpful. These statements are not going to convince undecided voters to come on over to your side. Instead, they just make the Democrats seem like the cool kids’ table at junior high — uncool Republicans will be sneered at as they walk by.
Sure, Heather Armstrong is really smart and cool and famous, and we all want to impress her by agreeing with her completely — even slavishly — in her comments. And I suppose the blog of a stated Democrat isn’t exactly the place to find Republican points of view. But seeing as how Heather specifically asked for conservative thoughts and ideas, you would think that her readers could pull it together enough to make the comments on that post, at least, welcoming to other points of view. Instead, most of them just confirmed the Republican idea that Democrats are more interested in being in the popular kids’ club, than interested in talking about policies and platforms.
Up here in Canada, we’re having a general election, too. I’m an undecided voter. I don’t want to hear anyone — candidates or their supporters — tell me non-useful things like, “He’s stupid and scary, and if you can’t see that, you’re an idiot.” There’s a lot of that kind of fear-mongering and mud-slinging going on, which is completely unhelpful to me. I want to know why the other party isn’t good for Canada. I want your reasons to be thoughtful and well-stated and true. I don’t want name-calling and a lot of back-patting about how your supporters are so much smarter than everyone else.
The Republicans don’t seem to have as big of an internet presence as the Democrats — at least among the websites I read — but the few things I have read from the conservative point of view are well phrased attacks on Obama. They aren’t always true, they aren’t always logical, but they do try to make a point, a point that will give voters something to think about, something to believe. So many of the anti-McCain and (especially) anti-Palin commentary is just a matter of making fun of them, as if their failings are so incredibly obvious that anyone who can’t see it is a dolt. That may be true, but it’s not productive to the process to act like your opinion is the only one that matters.
If you’re an Obama supporter and you want to sway some of those Republican votes, it’s time to start stepping up with some strong, effective arguments. Sure, show me a clip of Palin saying that proximity to Russia gives her foreign policy experience — but don’t just play it for comedy. Take it seriously. Tell me how McCain’s age and health issues mean that this woman might actually be in a room with representatives from the Middle East one day, with no experience on how to handle them. Tell me how in times of war or crises like 9/11, she’ll be completely reliant on advisors that we do not know the names of and haven’t elected. Tell me how just because Palin reminds you of your daughter or sister or librarian or next-door-neighbour does not qualify her for one of the most important jobs in the country. Tell me that it’s critical that the guy in charge be smart and experienced. Tell me that being a well-spoken college graduate does not mean that you are out-of-touch with the wants and needs of everyday Americans.
The race is close, Democrats — this is your chance to really make a difference. Don’t be stupid. Don’t blow it.